Listen: Nebraska FARMcast
Shannon Sand of the Center for Agricultural Profitability breaks down what it really takes to transition to organic production, from budgeting for the three-year wait to building a recordkeeping system that holds up under certification. Find this episode on your favorite platform here.
As consumer demand for organic food continues to grow, many producers are evaluating whether organic production could be a profitable addition to their operation. Organic products often receive price premiums and may provide access to new or specialized markets; however, the transition process can be lengthy and challenging. Producers considering organic certification must not only adapt their production practices but also develop robust recordkeeping systems that demonstrate compliance with federal regulations.
If a producer is considering organic certification, one has to look beyond just changing field practices. It is also important to build a robust, airtight recordkeeping system that proves you are in compliance with federal regulations.
Understanding the Reality of the Transition Period
Transitioning to organic production is not simply a matter of eliminating synthetic fertilizers and pesticides. Rather, it involves adopting a whole-farm management approach focused on soil health, biodiversity, ecological balance, and preventative management. While these principles can provide long-term benefits, implementing them often requires substantial changes to production systems, management practices, and business operations.
The first, and often tallest, hurdle is the 36-month transition period. Under the USDA National Organic Program (NOP), land must be managed without any prohibited substances for at least 36 months before you can harvest a certified organic crop.
The Financial Reality: During these three years, one will likely incur higher labor and management costs associated with organic production, but you won't receive the organic price premiums. For operations already running on narrow margins, this creates a significant cash-flow challenge that needs careful budgeting.
The transition can be tough on your numbers because yields frequently drop temporarily while you adapt to new management practices. Conventional systems rely on synthetic fertilizers and herbicides to handle nutrient deficiencies and weed outbreaks. Organic systems, however, rely on prevention.
Producers shifting to organic will need to look at:
- Longer, more complex crop rotations
- Heavy reliance on cover crops
- Increased mechanical cultivation
- Approved biological or cultural controls
All of these changes require extra labor, specialized equipment, and a steep management learning curve.
While producers cannot market crops as certified organic during the required 36-month transition period, some buyers have developed markets specifically for transitional products. These markets generally do not offer the same premiums as certified organic commodities, but they may provide prices that are higher than conventional market levels, helping offset some of the financial challenges associated with transition. Availability of transitional markets varies by region, commodity, and buyer, so producers should research opportunities and secure potential buyers before beginning the certification process.
Producers should also explore USDA programs designed to support organic transition efforts. The Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) offers assistance through programs such as the Environmental Quality Incentives Program (EQIP), which includes Organic Initiative practices that can help producers implement conservation measures commonly used in organic systems, such as cover crops, nutrient management, conservation crop rotations, and improved grazing systems. These programs may provide cost-share assistance to help offset the expense of adopting new production practices.
Additional support may be available through USDA's Farm Service Agency (FSA), which offers a variety of farm ownership and operating loan programs that can assist producers with cash-flow needs, equipment purchases, and other investments required during the transition period. Historically underserved, beginning, and small-scale producers may also qualify for targeted assistance programs.
The USDA Organic Certification Cost Share Program can also help reduce certification expenses by reimbursing a portion of eligible certification costs. In addition, producers can work with USDA conservation planners, Extension educators, and organic certification agencies to access technical assistance and educational resources that support the development of successful organic systems. Because program availability and funding levels can change over time, producers should contact their local USDA Service Center early in the planning process to learn about current opportunities.
Weed and Soil Fertility Management
Ask any transitioning producer, and they’ll tell you: weed management is one of the biggest headaches. Without conventional herbicides, you have to outsmart the weeds using integrated strategies like altered planting dates and highly competitive crop stands. In Nebraska and across the Great Plains, our erratic weather patterns make dryland weed control even more of a moving target.
Similarly, building soil fertility through compost, manure, and cover crops takes time. These practices absolutely improve soil structure and water infiltration over the long haul, but they don't offer the instant gratification of synthetic inputs. You have to monitor your nutrient availability constantly while balancing crop needs against strict certification rules.
Livestock
Livestock operations face their own set of challenges. Organic livestock production requires the use of certified organic feed, access to pasture for ruminants, and restrictions on certain medications and management practices. Producers must carefully evaluate whether organic markets provide sufficient premiums to offset increased feed costs and additional management requirements. Maintaining animal health while complying with organic standards requires proactive planning and close attention to nutrition, housing, and preventative care.
Market Access: Look Before You Leap
Before investing a single dollar into certification, it’s important to identify buyers and understand their specific market requirements.
Yes, organic markets offer premiums, but those premiums fluctuate based on supply, demand, and the specific commodity. Furthermore, transportation, storage, and handling requirements will look very different from conventional markets. Developing a solid marketing plan before transitioning is critical to evaluating whether the expected returns actually justify the investment.
The Paperwork: Master the Audit Trail
An often-overlooked challenge is the sheer volume of documentation required. Recordkeeping is the backbone of organic compliance, and frankly, it’s a major reason some producers walk away from the idea. The USDA requires certified operations to maintain detailed records that fully disclose all activities and transactions. You need a paper trail that can track a product all the way from the seed bag to the final sale, and one must keep these records for at least five years.
The roadmap for this is the Organic System Plan (OSP). This document outlines a producer’s production practices, approved inputs, monitoring procedures, and compliance strategies. It is reviewed annually by your certifying agency.
To keep the certifier happy, one must maintain several key categories of records:
| Record Category | What You Need to Track | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| Field Histories | Previous crops, land use, and input applications. | Proves no prohibited substances were used during the 36-month transition. |
| Input Records | Receipts, invoices, labels, and application logs for all fertilizers, seeds, and pest tools. | Verifies every product used complies with organic standards. |
| Production & Storage | Planting dates, varieties, harvest dates, yields, and cleaning logs for shared equipment. | Prevents commingling and proves organic products stayed segregated from conventional ones. |
| Sales & Marketing | Sales receipts, inventory records, and bills of lading. | Allows certifiers to do "trace-back" exercises to verify your volume sold matches your volume harvested. |
Note: Livestock operations must also maintain additional logs for certified feed purchases, pasture rotation days, animal IDs, and health treatments.
The Bottom Line
Fortunately, a producer’s recordkeeping system doesn't need to be overly complicated. Plenty of successful organic producers get by using spreadsheets, farm management software, or a disciplined paper-based binder system. The best system is simply the one you will actually use. Writing down activities as they happen throughout the season is infinitely easier than trying to reconstruct months of farm history the night before an inspection.
Transitioning to organic can open up excellent opportunities for diversification, new markets, and potentially better soil health. However, success depends on realistic financial expectations, adaptive management, and meticulous documentation. By understanding these challenges upfront and building a strong recordkeeping habit early, one can position their operation for long-term financial success.
References:
https://extension.psu.edu/transitioning-to-organic-crop-production
https://www.ams.usda.gov/sites/default/files/media/Organic%20Transition%20Guide%20v3.2.pdf
Francis, C. A., Shapiro, C. A., Kubik, C. J., Wortmann, C. S., & Little, R. S. (2017). Planning the transition to organic crop production (G2282). University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension.
Sarno, E. A., Francis, C. A., & Hansen, T. M. (2012). Certification process for organic production (G2163). University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension.
United States Department of Agriculture Agricultural Marketing Service. (n.d.). Organic recordkeeping: Guides, templates and other resources.
United States Department of Agriculture. (n.d.). National Organic Program.
University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension. (n.d.). Organic farming resources. CropWatch Nebraska.
National Center for Appropriate Technology. (n.d.). Organic production resources. ATTRA Sustainable Agriculture Program.
